Contested interpretation
Scholars and traditions disagree on aspects of this comparison. The tag and framing represent one editorial reading; readers are encouraged to consult primary sources directly.
Note how the name changes across traditions: Avraham, Abraham, Ibrahim.
PersonAbraham
Abraham is recognized across all three Abrahamic traditions as the founding patriarch who established monotheism. Called to leave Ur of the Chaldeans, he entered into a covenant with God. Lineage: Abraham + Hagar → Ishmael; Abraham + Sarah → Isaac → Jacob (Israel) → 12 Tribes. The Arab/Islamic prophetic line runs through Ishmael; the Israelite line through Isaac.
Open- Comparison
The Divine Call to Abraham
The Torah explicitly narrates God's call to Abraham to leave his homeland and go to a new land. Both Paul's letters and the Qur'an reference this call, presenting Abraham as a model of obedience to God. The three traditions share the foundational narrative of Abraham's departure as an act of faith.
Open - Comparison
Abraham's Covenant with God
All three traditions affirm that God entered into a special covenant with Abraham. The Torah establishes this as an everlasting covenant of land and lineage for the Jewish people. The New Testament, through Paul, reinterprets the covenant as fulfilled through faith rather than law. The Qur'an presents Ibrahim as an Imam for all humanity, with the covenant extending to righteous descendants. Each tradition affirms the covenant's divine origin and Abraham's central role, while understanding its scope and continuation differently.
Open - Person
Hagar
Hagar is the Egyptian handmaid of Sarah who becomes the mother of Ishmael, Abraham's firstborn son. When Sarah becomes jealous after the birth of Isaac, Hagar and Ishmael are expelled into the desert. In Islam, Hagar (Hajar) is a central figure — her running between Safa and Marwa in search of water is commemorated in the Hajj ritual (Sa'i). Lineage: Hagar + Abraham → Ishmael → 12 Arab tribes → Muhammad (through Adnan lineage).
Open - Person
Ishmael
Ishmael is Abraham's firstborn son by Hagar. In Judaism and Christianity he is the ancestor of Arab peoples, distinct from the covenant line through Isaac. In Islam, Ishmael (Isma'il) is a prophet of the highest rank, the one Abraham nearly sacrificed (not Isaac), and the co-builder of the Ka'ba in Mecca with Abraham. Lineage: Abraham + Hagar → Ishmael → 12 Princes (Gen 25) → Arab tribes → Muhammad (through Kedar line).
Open - Person
Isaac
Isaac is the son born to Abraham and Sarah in their old age, fulfilling God's promise. He is nearly sacrificed by Abraham (the Akedah/binding of Isaac) before God substitutes a ram. In Judaism and Christianity, he is the covenant heir through whom God's promises to Abraham continue. In Islam, Ishaq is a prophet and the father of Yaqub (Jacob). Lineage: Abraham + Sarah → Isaac → Jacob (Israel) → 12 Tribes.
Open The traditions disagree here. Notice that each names a different son.
ComparisonThe Akedah — Which Son Was Offered?
The story of Abraham's near-sacrifice of his son is shared by all three traditions and is one of the most theologically rich narratives in Abrahamic scripture. The Torah and New Testament are explicit: the son is Isaac (Yitzchak), Abraham's son through Sarah — the covenant heir. Islam agrees this is the supreme test of Abraham's faith, but Islamic tradition (supported by most classical commentators) holds that the son was Ishmael (Isma'il), Abraham's firstborn through Hagar. The Quran does not name the son in the sacrifice narrative (Surah 37:100–107), which has generated 1400 years of scholarly debate. At stake in this dispute is the question of which lineage — Israelite or Arab/Ishmaelite — carries the supreme covenantal narrative.
Open
Review the evidence
Five sourced questions ask what each tradition teaches—never which tradition is right.
Start the final quiz